Thursday, October 29, 2026

Book Review: It Looks Like You in the Dark by Mathilda Zeller

 

It Looks Like You in the Dark by Mathilda Zeller
 

288 pages, Hardcover

Published October 13, 2026 by Tor Nightfire

A couple of years back, there was an important revolution that happened in horror fiction.  The Never Whistle at Night Anthology, co-edited by local homey Shane Hawk, was like a boulder being dropped in a lake, and the ripples are spreading out constantly.  I honestly can’t keep up with all the things Shane is doing (although this friend of his just wants his novel that he explained to me a few years back). Never Whistle spent a crazy number of weeks on the indie bookstore bestseller list and won acclaim, so it was only a matter of time that the authors that Theodore Van Alst Jr. and Shane Hawk discovered started to release their own work, and thankfully I am here for it.  


Not sure she is the first to publish a full novel after being discovered in the anthology, but Mathilda Zeller did open Never Whistle, so for me it is a fitting first novel to read from this crew. It is an extension of her excellent story.  Here is what I said  at the time.“Mathilda Zeller opened the book with Kushtuka – The name of a Pacific Northwest mythological shape-shifting creature. The story starts with the narrator’s mother trying to get the main character is have the baby of the man she is having an affair with for money. The appearance of the shape-shifter in a story that starts off with this theme makes for an interesting opening story that mixes lore with questions of reality.”


The story is about Tapeesa, who just graduated high school and works in a seafood processing plant in the Inupiat village, her tiny, tight-knit hometown. Everyone in this small community knows each other too well.  She is tired of being dismissed by almost everyone except her mother, who still thinks she might be cursed. Mama could be on to something.  The monster of this creature feature is given a name by her grandmother: a “hungry creature- the kushtuka- appears to us in the form of someone we love.”


This novel takes the core elements of the story, the setting, characters, and the mythological shape-shifting creature into a novel that feels epic in comparison to the story, and due to the far north setting, it feels like the last season of True Detective, not a bad thing. The novel builds off the story, but it is with a few changed elements. It Looks Like You in the Dark is a strong debut. 


Zeller shows some serious chops with the horror elements. "Bloody footprints dotted the floor; blood spatters and smears covered the walls. The men weren't here, not anymore. Just pieces of men, entrails of men. I took a step forward, and my foot grazed something wet. It was an eye, bloodshot across the sclera; it rolled, revealing a blue iris.”


I suppose you could read this as a pure apolitical horror novel, and you could enjoy it for those elements. One of the natural features of indigenous horror novels is the natural way these stories comment on Colonialism, environmentalism, and racism without feeling preachy or overbearing. (Not that I have a problem with preachy fiction, I don’t.) 

 

I think this novel correctly points out, "Truth floats. You can tie it to a boulder the size of a mountain, drop it in the deepest part of the seas, but in the end, the truth will always break free and come to the surface and wash up on shore. Nothing can be hidden forever."


Tapessa is young, and it might seem like she is set up to be a final girl but the things she has to face in the end. A Powerful ending is just a cherry on top for a powerful reading experience. “Don't ask me how I knew. As I stood frozen, unable to move my flashlight, I understood that I was face-to-face with something wild, violent, and undeniably female.”

 

This is a simple horror novel, but that is exactly what it needed to be. It is written with the confidence of a veteran author, a great debut. The best thing I can say is I am already sold on whatever Zeller does next. Big Thumbs up!



No comments: